Yes, would be nice to get notified by Coinbase.
Cause even this chat… I mean it is not sending notifications :)) just need to verify message every day here 
1 Like
A post was merged into an existing topic: Holistic market analysis - PundiX
Has there been any movement here? Could you please provide an update on the latest conversation with coinbase on this issue?
1 Like
You’re right. It has been quiet, so I don’t know if that is a good thing or bad thing. I have tested removing some of my FX into a wallet and has failed yet again.
1 Like
No News is good news, when there is something to tell they will say something, otherwise the answer is the same they are actively in conversations with the exchange.
No news. Feels a little more like “how long can they wait until people stop caring?”. If I’m being honest.
1 Like
No communication is annoying. My personal thought:
Since enabling Fx is not an option, the logical way out of this is to have PundiAI listed on coinbase and airdrop PundiAI to FX holders at 100:1 ratio.
Why this hasn’t been implemented? I am not sure. May be there are some hurdles to get PundiAI listed on Coinbase. Could be regulatory, listing fees or the fact that PundiAI itself is in transition from pundi chain to BNB or ETH.
1 Like
If the hold up is due to PundiAI transition, it’s probably few months. My guess would be 1st Quarter of 2026.
Yeah I can agree to that. This won’t be a overnight thing. It might be something to resolve next year.
coinbase have not released personal wallet info as far as i know, as that would be a privacy breach or concerns, the project can not just fill your bags with PUNDIAI because they don’t have the individuals identifiable wallets. If the project had it this easy as a door way to your wallet this would of been over day 2. I’m telling you now coinbase is whom you need to pressure.
-
FYI - I don’t have any holdings on coin base. I am just sharing my thoughts with investors who are stuck.
-
Team will have to transfer PundiAI to the exchange and they would distribute it. Just like any airdrop program with CEXs. But for this, a) PundiAI will have be an active asset on the exchange, b) deposit and withdraw functionality must be there for the PundiAI.
Coinbase sharing Fx holders wallet information makes no sense. Those addresses are for private CEX wallets, how would team airdrop directly to those addresses ? Apart from the fact that why would Coinbase share any information with the team.
So in my opinion, all of this delay is related to getting PundiAI listed on Coinbase. Not sure how long will it take.
Won’t be quick, because PundiAI is transitioning itself to a different chain (based on the last information shared on the forums by Zac). I can only imagine it would be after the migration.
Being an investor in the Pundi project since 2018, I can assure the people stuck in Coinbase few things:
-
Your tokens won’t be lost. You will get your fare share of PundiAI.
-
The series of events have caused major losses for all of us (PundiAi and FX holders). But this delay may actually help to cover up your investment losses. I can see the project gaining a lot of traction by the time the Coinbase issue is resolved.
-
I know the team, they are dedicated to the project. They will try their best to make this project successful.
2 Likes
on your first point sending PUNDIAI to coinbase for them to distribute would be a great idea, BUT that may still constitute being a swap, even though they do not go through a swap contract it’s really the same action the giving of 1 for the other, because the FX will still need disposal.
the team has given them more that 1 option that could be one; who knows.
point 2 about addresses if Coinbase can’t do the swap, the project can drop PUNDIAI but they can’t with out a minimum of wallet addresses.
eth/PUNDIAI do not need a listing, they just need to be able to withdraw, OUR CSP community spend pool, would have way more then needed to cover this small amount on coinbase, it’s only like 0.2% in PUNDIAI of supply.
another way if coinbase wanted to go out of their way to help; would be to have all FX holders supply an Eth self custody wallet address to coinbase, coinbase can verify their quantity associated to each address, the project can check the total supply held by coinbase via ether scan. once the project has all the self custody wallets and the numbers add up; the project could just airdrop PUNDIAI to peoples self custody addresses, that way nothing has happened on the exchange. no rules broken coinbase can burn the FX.
This is not a Coinbase problem, so expecting them to go out of their normal business is not fair.
The only way PundiAI withdrawal method on ETH will work is if PundiAi is listed as a coin on the exchange.
1 Like
Coinbase are in control of the funds, they are fully responsible to act, the PUNDIAI do not need a listing to be withdrawn from the exchange it’s only an asset added to an eth wallet they already hold for you, secondary tokens of eco-system coins have been promotion dropped to people through exchanges before without listing; that people are only able to withdraw with no trade.
Crypto is their business they have an obligation to look after their customers, It shouldn’t be a debate on if they should feel like going out of their way, It already should have been done, why are people such a suck up to exchanges. the project want’s to replace these holders coin it can’t be done with out the exchanges help.
You are biased.
Is it Coinbase’s fault that one of their listed token got hacked and the project froze the chain because they have no other way to handle the stolen funds?
Or is Coinbase’s fault that a project decided to upgrade to a new token? Shouldn’t the team have made sure one way or other that Coinbase will upgrade to PundiAI when the chain upgrades?
How is it that the team didn’t align the upgrade with the highest trading volume exchange for their token? And then they ignore it when their old token is traded on the biggest exchange with manipulated price.
FX represented this project even after the upgrade. All this mess has been exaggerated because team ignored FX even though their reputation was tied to it. Now it is team’s responsibility to restore everything, not Coinbase.
3 Likes
Not Bias, I’m stating how i believe the project needs to resolve the issue, It’s the hackers fault not the exchange or the project, talks with exchange about the swap were long before it started.
people keep building speculation of what you believe - this do not change the requirements of whats required to resolve the issue.
we can’t even definitively say what they have talked about or organising. it serves no purpose to continuously draw blame and should haves; it’s about what the situation is and how it needs to happen to be resolved for all parties involved; which has a boarder scope I think than you can imagine; in which needs time and patience.
Its absolutely the projects responsibility to secure its contract
2 Likes
the contract has been secured, that’s why the funds are stuck.